Do I Need an Engineer for My Shoreline Project?

The short answer

Most dock, pier and boat lift jobs don’t need an engineer. Breakwaters, failed structures and complex shoreline work often do. If you aren’t sure, start with the state’s free Shoreline Erosion Advisory Service, which will look at your shoreline and review a contractor’s plans at no cost.

The trap many homeowners fall into

It usually goes like this. A homeowner has an erosion problem and calls a contractor or a permit company. They get a set of drawings that look professional, the permit is approved, and the work gets built. Everything along the way felt official, so it felt like a sure thing. A few years later, the shoreline is losing ground again, and the homeowner is paying to fix the fix.

Nice drawings don’t mean the design will work. Permit drawings are made to show the agencies what will be built and where. Clean lines, measurements and a company logo tell you the drawings were prepared with care. They don’t tell you anyone worked out whether the structure will stand up to your waves, your currents and your neighbors’ shorelines.

That’s not a knock on good permit agents. A clear, complete application has real value. It just isn’t the same as engineering.

An engineer isn’t a guarantee either. Shorelines are hard to predict, and no one can promise a result. But a licensed engineer is trained to do the analysis behind a design, and on complex projects that raises your chances that the finished work does what you paid for.

Whether to hire one is your call. The point of this guide is that you make that call knowing the difference.

A permit isn’t a guarantee that the design will work

Many homeowners assume an approved permit means someone checked the plan. As we understand it, that isn’t what the permit review does. VMRC, the Army Corps of Engineers, DEQ and your local wetlands board look at a project’s effect on wetlands, the bottom of the waterway, navigation and your neighbors. They don’t test whether the structure will hold up or do what you want it to do.

We looked through recent shoreline permit filings in Mathews and Gloucester counties. The drawings ranged from careful computer drawn plans signed by a licensed engineer to hand sketches on notebook paper, sometimes for the same kind of breakwater. Both kinds can be approved. An approved permit tells you the project is allowed, not that it will work.

Do you need an engineer?

This is our general guidance, not a rule. Your site, your neighbors’ shorelines and the size of the job all matter.

Usually not needed

  • A floating dock, pier or boat lift
  • Replacing a bulkhead with one the same size, in the same place
  • Small riprap repairs

Worth asking about

  • A new stone revetment or a living shoreline with a sill
  • Groins
  • A new bulkhead that is taller or longer than the old one

Wise to hire an engineer

  • Breakwaters, especially with gaps between them
  • A structure that has already failed or isn’t doing its job, such as sand washing out or scour forming
  • Shoreline open to the Bay or a wide river, where storm waves are big
  • Several structures that work together, such as breakwaters, a sill and added sand
  • A bulkhead close to your house

Free help first

Shoreline Erosion Advisory Service (SEAS). Run by the Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation since 1980, SEAS helps private landowners with erosion problems, free of charge. Its services include site visits, written reports, plan reviews and construction inspections. That means you can ask SEAS to look over a contractor’s or agent’s plans before you sign anything. Its staff give advice; they aren’t a private engineer you hire. Contact SEAS.

Virginia Institute of Marine Science (VIMS). The Center for Coastal Resources Management at VIMS answers homeowner questions about shoreline management and lists a contact on its Managing My Shoreline page. VIMS doesn’t fund or build projects.

A written report from SEAS is also useful to hand to an engineer or contractor, so everyone starts from the same facts.

How to check an engineer

  • Ask for the engineer’s name and license number. Look it up on the state’s DPOR License Lookup. A licensed engineer shows up as a Professional Engineer with an active license.
  • A job title isn’t a license. “Environmental engineer,” “shoreline engineer” or an engineering degree on a bio doesn’t mean the person holds a Virginia engineering license. Only the DPOR record tells you that.
  • Don’t rely on the stamp alone. A licensed engineer’s seal on drawings shows who took responsibility for the design. But permit drawings often aren’t sealed, even when an engineer worked on them. If the plans have no seal, ask who designed them.
  • For complex work, ask for it in writing. Ask for a written assessment, or final drawings, signed by the engineer before you agree to a construction price.
  • Firms can register too. An engineering company can hold its own registration with DPOR, which lists the licensed engineers connected to it.

Questions to ask before you sign

  • Who designed this plan?
  • Is that person a licensed Professional Engineer in Virginia? What’s the license number?
  • For breakwaters: how did you choose the gap width, the height and the distance from shore?
  • What will this do to my neighbors’ shorelines?
  • Have you built this kind of structure on a shoreline like mine? Can I see one that’s a few years old?
  • If it doesn’t work as planned, what happens next?

Some contractors design their own work, and many do it well. These questions aren’t a test of anyone’s honesty. They help you know what you’re getting before the work begins.

Related guides

Do you need a permit agent? · Waterfront permits: where to start · Understanding contractor licenses

This guide is general information, not legal or engineering advice. Every shoreline is different, so get advice for your own site before starting work. Sources: Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation, Shoreline Erosion Advisory Service; Virginia Institute of Marine Science, Center for Coastal Resources Management, Managing My Shoreline and Shoreline Permit Handbook; DPOR, Board for Architects, Professional Engineers, Land Surveyors, Certified Interior Designers and Landscape Architects, License Lookup; 757 Waterfront review of 2025 and 2026 public VMRC permit filings in Mathews and Gloucester counties. Last reviewed November 2026.